Super Bowl Contender

Is the Eagles offense good enough to be a Super Bowl contender right now?
The article argues that with the return of healthy players such as Donovan McNabb, and L.J. Smith, consistently strong play from the offensive line, Brian Westbrook, improved play from the receivers, and improved Red Zone efficiency that Eagles are a contender.

Yes, all of the article's points are valid, but the answer is, "NO". I am of the belief that based on the Eagles offensive style of play that they are in need a dominant #1 receiver. Otherwise they struggle closing games out. The Eagles were criticized for not being able to get over the hump, and win the NFC title. They signed Owens, and went to the Super Bowl. Since then we haven't even been back to the NFC Championship game.

If the Eagles acquire a dominant #1 receiver it would produce tremendous dividends. Giving McNabb a play maker at the wide out position will alleviate some of the workload that is currently draped across the shoulders of Brian Westbrook. The Birds need him in the lineup. Westbrook's workload contributes too, if not is the cause of his nagging injuries. Two play makers are always better than one.

Not only would B. West benefit from having one, so would Tight End L.J. Smith. Provided that he is healthy Smith is a very effective Red Zone threat. He becomes even more effective when defenses cannot focus their coverages on the Tight End.

Having a dominant #1 will bring about improved play from the other receivers. A perfect example of this is Wes Welker, and the Patriots. Because there was so much focus on Moss (mainly), and Stallworth, it left Welker open underneath. His number were unbelievable. 112 receptions, 1175 yards, 8 TDs, and 10.5 average yards per catch. Combine Kevin Curtis with another play maker on the other side, and you can take quite a bit of pressure off of Brown, Baskett, Avant, Westbrook, Smith, and even Donovan. If the defense has to be concerned with the receivers, tight end, and running back you are taking away another possible pass rusher.

It's no secret that the Eagles are pass first run second team. The lack of consistency at the receiver position combined with pass happy play calling has cost the them several close games. If you aren't going to run the ball in the 4th quarter of a close game, you had better have some receivers that will make the necessary plays to close out the game.

In the Eagles offense having a top tier receiver has a trickle down effect. Westbrook isn't being weighed on so heavily, make plays, and remain healthy. L.J. Smith becomes even more dangerous target. Other receivers get better looks due to the change in coverage. Fewer pass rushers for make the offensive lines job of protecting McNabb easier. When the line protects Donovan it gives him time to throw, and reduces the likelihood of him getting injured. They need to get a high caliber receiver. If they are going to continue to be a pass first team the Eagles are going to need one to assist closing out games.



Additional Reference from Gunna20 from Yard Barker.